If you want an old-timey dining experience without too much kitsch, this Gettysburg restaurant may be a good choice for you. The Dobbin House Tavern featured delicious gourmet food, excellent service, and a great candlelit atmosphere. It was bustling with activity on this fall weekend night, but our food still came out hot and our server never seemed frazzled. This is a popular place, so I highly recommend advance reservations. We would have been waiting forever to get in if we had not planned ahead.
Link to my TripAdvisor Review and others for this restaurant
Link to my TripAdvisor Profile