We stayed for one night in Cumberland over the summer, and Puccini Restaurant was recommended to us by the innkeeper at The Bruce House Inn. It proved to have a delicious menu served by friendly staff, and aside from the screaming kid in our section, we had no complaints. It had a pretty ample amount of space and it’s in a fairly remote area, so I don’t think reservations are necessary, but it can’t hurt to call ahead to check on the wait times. If you have an extra few minutes, check out The Arts Place, located a few doors down from the restaurant. The shop features handmade wares from local artists, and we found several beautiful, unique ceramic pieces for our home there.
Link to my TripAdvisor Review and others for this restaurant
Link to my TripAdvisor profile